Thoughts from the Founder5 min read

Holons and why I build with specialised intelligence

A holon is whole in itself and part of something larger. It's the right shape for the intelligence that will work for you.

A fern frond unfurling, its spiral made of smaller spirals, with dotted frames marking the parts inside the whole

You already know plenty of holons. The grill cook in a restaurant kitchen owns the whole job of the grill, and answers to the head chef and whatever's on the tickets. A goalkeeper is complete at one job and still part of a team. A payroll team knows payroll inside out, and it's part of a business. Each has its own work and its own edges, and each fits inside something bigger.

I really don't like the word agent. An agent is a general helper you hand your keys to and hope it works out the rest. To do that, it has to decide for itself what the job is. It fills in the details according to a best, most logical guess. And whatever it decides, you didn't define.

I prefer specialised intelligence. And the best word I know for it is almost sixty years old.

What a holon is

In 1967 Arthur Koestler published The Ghost in the Machine. He noticed that nothing in nature is only a whole or only a part. A cell is a whole, and part of an organ. An organ is a whole, and part of a body. A person is a whole, and part of a family, a team, a town. He called each of these a holon, and the nested structure they make a holarchy.

Koestler saw every holon facing two ways at once. Looking inward, it's complete. It knows its own job and gets on with it. Looking outward, it's a part. It serves something larger and answers to it. That two-way shape is how living things can be so complicated and still hold together.

Koestler gave us the word. I want to make it something you can use.

Why the shape matters

A pit crew has one person on each wheel, one on the jack and one on fuel. Each does a single job, perfectly, in seconds, and the car is gone. Nobody wanders the garage looking for something useful to do. That's why it's fast, and why it's safe. It's the lesson of Ford's factory floor again: focus makes the work easy to see.

A holon in Decidr works the same way. Each one has a single job, whether that's a task type, a process or a function. It has a goal defined as a range, a budget and a period. And it has a status you can read at a glance: green, orange or red.

Holons nest. Task specialists sit inside process managers, which sit inside function executives, which sit inside your organisation, with you at the top. What you need to know rises to you. What you don't stays where it is.

Why a general agent has to be taken on faith

A general agent's job is to work out what to do. That means its scope is open. Today it drafts an email, tomorrow it moves money or rewrites a plan, and nobody listed those things in advance. You can't set a result range for a job that has no edges, so you can't tell green from red. All you can do is read what it did afterwards and decide whether you liked it. That's review, and it isn't control.

Trust comes from knowing what something will and won't do, then checking that it did. With an open scope you get neither. The cleverer the agent gets, the more decisions it makes that you'll never see. And when it goes wrong, it goes wrong across everything it touches, because it's all one thing.

I'm not against general intelligence. For exploring a hard problem, or something you'll only do once, a brilliant generalist is exactly right. I just don't think it should run your life or your business.

Why holons are better for most things

I think most of what a person or business needs is the same few jobs, done again and again. Pay the invoice. Plan the week's meals. Chase the quote. Work like that has a clear job and a clear result, so it suits something built to do one job.

A holon's scope is fixed, so you know what it'll touch and what it won't. Its goal is a range, so every period you know whether it worked. A mistake stays small, because a red holon stops and its work is reallocated while everything else keeps running. It gets better at one thing instead of being average at many, and because each holon is a defined thing, people can compete to build a better one. That's where the marketplaces come from. And because each holon answers to the one above it, nothing acts without a goal sitting over it.

That's trust you can check. The superstar generalist asks for it up front.

Three ways to get things done

There are really only three. You can do it yourself, and that stops at the hours in your day. You can leave it undone, which is where most good ideas end up. Or you can get others to do a lot more for you. Until now that third one belonged to people with a team and a budget. I think holons are how it opens up to everyone else.

It changes what's worth being good at. Holding a vision, defining the result you want as a range and delegating the rest are becoming the skills that matter most. And it starts somewhere ordinary: collecting what you know and getting it organised, because a specialist can only work from what it can find.

What's coming

You'll meet holons in LifeOS and BusinessOS. Some come installed, built to be excellent from day one. Others you'll choose from marketplaces as they open, built by people who are incredibly good at one particular thing.

What we get to find out

How quiet a life can get when hundreds of holons are working on thousands of tasks. And which ones people grow fond of, the way they're fond of a car that has never let them down. I don't know yet. I'm looking forward to finding out.

Why now

If you're great at one job, you're already the shape of a holon. You know that job inside out, and you answer to something bigger than it. What's missing is a way to capture how you do it, so it can run without you in the room. The people who describe their craft well, early on, help set the pattern for everyone who comes after. The people who are good at what they do are normally much better than the average. So they're looking for ways to become better.

Join the Innovators Circle on any page of the Decidr site.

PaulFounder, Decidr

Linked from this post

Linked pages and posts